There's something you do in every important conversation without knowing you're doing it. A position you take toward yourself and toward the other person: an unspoken belief about who is OK and who isn't. You don't say it out loud. Often you're not even aware of it. But it shapes the tone, the reactions and the outcome of the conversation more than any communication technique.
This model comes from Transactional Analysis and is called life positions, or the OK/Not-OK matrix, developed by psychiatrist Thomas Harris in I'm OK, You're OK, one of the best-selling popular psychology books of all time.
I'm OK, you're OK is the basic position of a healthy relationship. You start from the premise that you are both people of worth, with legitimate points of view, with the right to make mistakes and the right to be heard. Conflicts in this position lead to negotiation, compromise and solutions. It's the Adult position in Transactional Analysis: present, balanced, focused on solving things.
I'm OK, you're not OK: the position of superiority. The other person is the problem. They're wrong, they're incompetent, they need to be corrected or punished. From this position you criticize, you judge, you hand down verdicts, sometimes without even realizing it. The inner signal: “what an idiot, how can anyone think like that”.
I'm not OK, you're OK: the position of inferiority. The other person is right by definition. You're the one who's wrong, you're not good enough, you have to justify yourself. You put up with unfair criticism, you absorb behavior you don't deserve, you say yes when you mean no. The inner signal: “God, I'm so stupid, it must be my fault”.
I'm not OK, you're not OK: the position of hopelessness about relationships. Nothing works, nobody can be trusted, everything is a failure waiting to happen. It's the rarest position in everyday interactions, but it shows up in severe burnout, in chronically toxic relationships or in moments of extreme exhaustion.
This is the central point, and the theory captures it perfectly. Under normal conditions, with mental resources to spare, the prefrontal cortex can moderate your reactions and keep you in the OK-OK position, even in difficult conversations. You can listen, you can see things from the other person's side, you can find compromises.
Under stress (time pressure, tiredness, a high-stakes conflict, a threat to your status) the prefrontal cortex competes with the amygdala, and it often loses. That's when your default stress position comes back: that old belief, formed in childhood, about where you stand in relation to others when things get difficult.
Under stress, some people become attackers. Others become victims. Others switch between the two, depending on who they're dealing with.
And the most important thing: under stress, we're convinced we're right.
This is the most insidious part of the mechanism. We don't notice that we've slipped into a Not-OK position. We feel we're seeing the situation clearly. That other people really are incompetent, or that we really have made a mistake we can't undo. Conviction feels like clarity: subjective certainty can't be told apart from objective truth, especially once the amygdala has taken over.
That's why the advice “think rationally in a conflict” is almost useless. You can't think rationally when you're in survival mode. What you can do is recognize the signal, the inner voice saying “I'm so stupid” or “what an idiot”, as a sign that you've left the OK-OK position. Not as the truth about the situation.
A pause isn't a communication technique, it's a neurological intervention. When you realize you've gone into automatic attack or submission mode, stepping out of the conversation for a few minutes (a short walk, some light physical activity, a few slow breaths) lowers your cortisol enough for the prefrontal cortex to get back in the game.
Picking the conversation up again from a calm state doesn't mean you've given in or that the other person has won. It means you've chosen to have a real conversation instead of an exchange of stress positions. That's how you get off the hamster wheel.
And from the OK-OK position, solutions show up almost by themselves. Not because the situation has changed, but because you have access to all of your thinking again.
Which of the three Not-OK positions do you slip into most often under stress: attack, submission or hopelessness?